Most first-time visitors don't choose one for the whole trip — they mix both. A hotel makes sense as a base in Tokyo or Osaka, where you want convenience and don't plan to spend much time in the room. A ryokan makes sense for a night or two in a hot spring town, or anywhere you want the stay itself to be part of the experience. The comparison below is about knowing which nights are which.
If You Book a Ryokan, Know This First
Five small things that make the difference between feeling like a guest and feeling like a tourist.
Remove your shoes at the entrance
The genkan (entrance foyer) has a step. Remove your outdoor shoes before stepping up. You'll be given slippers for inside.
Yukata etiquette
The yukata (cotton robe) is for wearing around the ryokan, not outside. Left side over right — the opposite way is for the deceased.
Onsen rules
Wash thoroughly at the shower station before entering the hot spring bath. No swimwear in traditional onsen. Many don't admit guests with visible tattoos — check before booking.
Futon setup
Your room typically arrives as a sitting room; staff will lay the futon while you're at dinner. Don't move the low table — it signals where the futon goes.